Not So Black And White

It has come to my attention, for reasons that will not be disclosed here, that there seems to be a number of different cookies going by the name "Black And White Cookie". And since I spent the entire weekend working at the House Of Torture so that we could close month end on time AND IT STILL ISN'T DONE, I feel completely justified in posting this at work. So, let us discuss B&W cookies. I present to you exhibit A.

It would appear from my research this afternoon, that this is the version most people would call a B&W cookie. One side chocolate, one side ... uh ... vanilla? This was confirmed by a trip to The Black And White Cookie Blog. It seems that the author of this blog only taste tests this particular variety. However, in California, or at least at the bakery around the corner from work ...

... this is a Black & White Cookie. A chocolate cookie with chunks of white chocolate. In the interest of science I had this particular variety today. It was tasty. Very tasty, in fact. Just to make matters worse, this bakery will actually send you e-mail alerts when they're ready to take another batch out of the oven. How anyone is supposed to lose any weight with that kind of conspiracy going on is beyond me. However, I digress.

So dear readers (all two of you), please enlighten me. Which is the definitive B&W cookie? Is it Exhibit A or B? Have you tried both? If not, I feel that it is necessary that you go out and try either one or both and report back here.

File your report in the comments and I will once again attempt to give away stuff. Cookie reports will be due by Saturday, 6pm PST. Prizes will follow. This is your mission, should you choose to accept it.